Predsjednik Etičkog foruma HNIP-a opet malo plagira, ovaj put je tekst prepisao s Wikipedije
Jure Vujić se prije 4 godine zbog plagiranja ispričavao profesoru Joviću
Nekadašnji zaposlenik Ministarstva vanjskih i europskih poslova i trenutni direktor Instituta za geopolitiku i strateška istraživanja, ali i predsjednik Etičkog foruma Hrvatskog društva novinara i publicista, Jure Vujić, opet je uhvaćen u plagiranju.
Nakon što se prije četiri godine morao ispričati profesoru Dejanu Joviću, nakon što je gotovo doslovno prepisao tri stranice njegova članka, Vujić je sada posegnuo za tekstom s Wikipedije. Danas je to prvi objavio portal Forum.tm u velikom tekstu čije dijelove u nastavku prenosimo.
Tekst povučen u zadnji trenutak
Vujićev članak “Eastern Mediterranean as gravitation centre od geopolitical battle for Euroasia” trebao je izaći u časopisu zagrebačkog Fakulteta političkih znanosti “Europske studije”, ali je u zadnji trenutak povučen jer je uredništvo primijetilo da je početak članka prepisao s web stranice na kojoj većinu članaka može mijenjati svatko s pristupom Internetu.
Iako članak nije tiskan, objavljem je na Hrčku, središnjem portalu znanstvenih i stručnih časopisa. Tekst je ubrzo skinut, ali poveznica je i dalje online. Na izravno pitanje o plagiranju, Vujić je Forumu rekao kako mu je “smiješno da se ljude proziva za nekakve plagijate i kvaziplagijate, a da se zna kako se masovno autoplagira i kompilira”. Dodao je i kako “Wikipedija može i ne mora biti stručno-znanstveni izvor” te da je ovdje isključivo riječ o “političkom obračunu s ciljem osobne diskvalifikacije”.
Sporni dijelovi Vujićeva teksta
A kako piše Forum.tm, ovo su sporni dijelovi teksta.
Vujić: “Eurasia is the combined continental landmass of Europe and Asia.”
Wikipedia: “Eurasia is the combined continental landmass of Europe and Asia.”
Vujić: “Located primarily in the Northern and Eastern Hemispheres, it is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean on the west, the Pacific Ocean to the east, the Arctic Ocean on the north, and by Africa, the Mediterranean Sea, the Pacific Ocean and the Indian Ocean to the south. The division between Europe and Asia as two different continents is a historical and cultural construct, with no clear physical separation between them; thus, in some parts of the world, Eurasia is recognized as the largest of five or six continents.”
Wikipedia: “The term is a portmanteau of its constituent continents. Located primarily in the Northern and Eastern Hemispheres, it is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean to the west, the Pacific Ocean to the east, the Arctic Ocean to the north, and by Africa, the Mediterranean Sea, and the Indian Ocean to the south. The division between Europe and Asia as two different continents is a historical and cultural construct, with no clear physical separation between them; thus, in some parts of the world, Eurasia is recognized as the largest of five or six continents.”
Vujić: “Physiographically, Eurasia is a single continent. The concepts of Europe and Asia as distinct continents date back to antiquity and their borders are geologically arbitrary, with the Ural and Caucasus ranges being the main delimiters between the two. Eurasia is connected to Africa at the Suez Canal, and Eurasia is sometimes combined with Africa as the supercontinent Afro-Eurasia.”
Wikipedia: “Physiographically, Eurasia is a single continent. The concepts of Europe and Asia as distinct continents date back to antiquity and their borders are geologically arbitrary, with the Ural and Caucasus ranges being the main delimiters between the two. Eurasia is connected to Africa at the Suez Canal, and Eurasia is sometimes combined with Africa as the supercontinent Afro-Eurasia.”